Halloween is a holiday of classic thrills, and nothing is quite as timeless as a bag full of candy at the end of a night of Trick-or-Treating. But not all Halloween candies are created equal. The ideal treats in 2024 balance taste, nostalgia, and a good variety that makes kids eager to visit the next house. So, what’s the best candy to give out this Halloween? Let’s explore a few top choices and why they hit the mark!

1. Reese's Peanut Butter Cups: The Classic Choice

It’s almost impossible to find a Halloween best-seller list without Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups at the top. Why? It’s the simple, but perfect, combination of chocolate and peanut butter. Reese's Cups are individually wrapped, making them easy for handing out, and their mini versions offer a perfectly portioned treat for eager trick-or-treaters. In 2024, this timeless candy shows no signs of going out of style, and it's great for Halloween because it has a nostalgic appeal for parents too!

Why they’re great: The unique taste and satisfying texture make Reese’s a Halloween staple. Plus, their orange packaging suits the Halloween color scheme, adding an extra festive feel!

2. Sour Patch Kids: The Perfect Balance of Sweet and Sour

For kids who love a burst of flavor, Sour Patch Kids are a favorite. The candy’s classic tagline, “Sour. Sweet. Gone.” holds true even today. In 2024, Sour Patch Kids rank highly on the candy wishlist because of their tangy flavor that makes them stand out from the pack of traditional chocolate treats.

Why they’re great: They’re different from the average chocolate bar, which makes them memorable. Sour Patch Kids also cater to the younger crowd who might prefer sour candy over sweeter options, adding some diversity to your candy bucket.

3. M&M’s: A Pop-in-Your-Mouth Treat

You can’t go wrong with M&M’s. The small, colorful candies are popular because they’re easy to share, come in various flavors, and have an appealing crunch. Whether you go with the classic milk chocolate, peanut, or a seasonal Halloween variety, M&M’s are a welcome addition to any Trick-or-Treat haul.

Why they’re great: They’re bite-sized, sharable, and unlikely to melt, so they work well for trick-or-treaters. Plus, they’re allergy-friendly compared to some peanut-laden options and come in fun Halloween packaging.

4. Snickers: Satisfying and Filling

Snickers bars are a solid, reliable choice that satisfy even the biggest appetites. With peanuts, caramel, nougat, and chocolate, they’re packed with flavor and a bit of substance. This makes them a great choice for trick-or-treaters looking for something a bit more filling.

Why they’re great: Snickers have a bit of everything—crunch, sweetness, and chewiness—which makes them a top choice for older kids and adults. They’re also easy to find in mini and fun-size bars, making them a practical option.

5. Skittles: A Rainbow of Flavor

In recent years, Skittles have made a strong comeback as a go-to Trick-or-Treat candy. Kids love Skittles for the variety of flavors, and they come in small, easy-to-carry packages that are perfect for Halloween. In 2024, Skittles remain a bright and colorful addition to any candy mix.

Why they’re great: They’re perfect for kids who want to taste “the rainbow” and offer a fruit-flavored alternative to chocolate-based options.

6. Twix: The Crunchy Caramel Favorite

Twix bars are unique among candy bars for their crunchy, biscuit base topped with caramel and chocolate. They’re available in both mini and full-size options and are particularly popular with fans of caramel-flavored treats. Twix offers something a little different from traditional candy bars, which adds a fun twist to the Halloween lineup.

Why they’re great: The combination of textures makes them memorable, and they’re a slightly less common pick, which makes them a novelty in a candy bucket.

7. Kit Kat: The Perfectly Snackable Bar

Kit Kats offer a satisfying crunch that makes them a hit with people of all ages. The combination of crisp wafers and chocolate has given Kit Kat a spot among the top candies year after year, and 2024 is no different. Plus, they’re sharable, easy to eat, and come in both mini and fun-size options.

Why they’re great: The snackable, breakable nature of Kit Kats makes them a fun and easy treat for kids of all ages. They also come in seasonal flavors, so you might find unique varieties in stores around Halloween.
 

Candy That’s Still Popular, But Better in Moderation

While it’s tempting to load up on every candy available, some options are better given in moderation. Gummy candies, hard candies, and anything super sticky (like caramels) might be a treat best reserved for younger kids. These options are delicious but can be tough on little teeth and sometimes melt or stick together in the trick-or-treat bag.

Why Thoughtful Candy Choices Matter

In 2024, the best Halloween candy isn’t just about tradition or sugar levels. It’s about creating a mix that makes kids excited with every visit to the next door. Offering a variety ensures you’re prepared for different preferences, whether kids want sweet chocolate, sour candies, or something chewy. And remember, candy preferences also give you an easy way to spark conversations with trick-or-treaters, making the evening even more fun.

So when you’re making your candy choices this Halloween, think about those classics with staying power and add in a few unique twists.